Best Pan for Cinnamon Rolls (Round Pans, Sheet Pans, & More)

Best Pans for Cinnamon Rolls
Spread the love

If you're looking to make some ooey gooey cinnamon rolls to melt in your mouth, you're going to need a great pan. Luckily for you, we've already completed your homework by compiling a list of the best pans for cinnamon rolls. From round pounds to square pounds, from small to large, you're sure to find the perfect pan for your cinnamon roll needs!

We've taken effectiveness, quality, versatility, price, our experiences, and overall customer experiences to help us determine which pans are truly the best. 

Cinnamon Roll Pans (Top 5) Compared

Prices and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Best Cinnamon Roll Pans (Top 5 List)

We’ve found a list of the top 5 products serves users best. It allows us enough space to provide alternative products that suit different people’s needs without providing too many choices, making the overall decision harder. We hope you find our top cinnamon roll pans list useful.

#1 Farberware 52103 Nonstick Bakeware Baking Pan

Why we chose it

It’s the best value option when it comes to cinnamon roll pans. You could literally buy it only to make cinnamon rolls twice a year, and it still wouldn’t be a bad investment at its price point. Overall, most of everybody seem happy with their pans. Its heavy gauge so it feels sturdy and durable. The pans even stack inside each other if you want to purchase more than one. It’s a reactive pan, so it’ll rust if used  with acidic foods such as pasta sauce. Overall, you simply can’t get this durability and quality at a better bargain.

Biggest Concerns

To our surprise, some people actually complained about the non-stick coating. While most say it works fine, even over time, others persisted with their complaints. Overall, the non-stick coating works fairly well. If you can avoid the dishwasher, you’ll make it last much longer. However, for this price, you honestly shouldn’t expect it to last forever.

Buy on Amazon

#2 Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick 8-Inch Square Cake Pans, Set of 2

Why we chose it?

For us, we love smaller square pans for cinnamon rolls. It’s very similar to a round pan in how to quickly and evenly heats up the cinnamon rolls. However, overall we find more uses for this pan. From cakes to other deserts such as brownies, we feel there is more value to the pan’s usefulness overall. They automatically come in a 2-pack so you’re not spending much on a per pan basis, which is always a nice bonus.

Biggest Concern

The manufacturer lacks some important info. For example, we couldn’t find any information regarding the max temperature the pan can be heated to on a merchant site and the manufacturer’s. This should be information that I don’t even need to look for to find. Overall though, there have been no bad reports regarding the pan not being able to handle normal household oven temperatures.

Buy on Amazon

#3 Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick 3-Piece Round Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Why we chose it

It’s our favorite set based on customer reviews, quality construction, and price. You can always buy multiple pans from a specific merchant, but sometimes it’s easier to buy a pre-made set, not to mention cheaper. Overall, we find the durability and quality to match the other products on the list. The non-stick coating has worked well for everybody, and their cakes have slid straight out of them. In terms of cinnamon rolls we recommend using the 8″ or 10″ pans in this set. The 6″ pan may be a bit too small for your cinnamon roll batches.

Biggest Concern

Unfortunately the pans in this set don’t have handles you can grip on the sides. It’s still considered a cake pan, so they shouldn’t be hard to put in or take out of the oven. 

Buy on Amazon

#4 Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 9-Inch Square Baking Pan with Lid, Set of 2

Why we chose it

What’s better than making some delicious cinnamon rolls? Having easy access to a lid to store them. That’s truly why we find this in our list. We’ve already highlighted a 8×8 Wilton square pan. These are slightly larger and include lids. So anytime you’re making yummy treats, you’re going to have an easy way to store it. Overall, the lids are sturdier than you may expect for them being plastic.

Biggest Concern

Some people have had a little trouble getting the lids off the pan, especially the first couple of times. The lids simply attach really well, so it may take a few tries to get used to how they need to be taken off quickly.

Buy on Amazon

#5 Circulon 47107 Nonstick Bakeware Set with Nonstick Cookie Sheets

Why we chose it?

Baking sheets can actually be a great way to bake cinnamon rolls. They’re larger if you have bigger batches. We personally like pans that keep the rolls together for the best tasting results, but everybody has their own style, and we respect that. Plus, if you have more uses for a cookie sheet than a smaller cake pan, it may make more sense to try and knock out two birds with one stone.

Biggest Concern

Despite its claim to withstand 450 degrees Fahrenheit, some customers have reported warping at 400°F. While most baking goods don’t require high temperatures, if you’re looking for a set of baking sheets with a higher max temperature, we can’t blame you.

How to choose the Best Cinnamon Roll Pan

To determine what pan may work best for you when making cinnamon rolls, you need to figure out a few things.

Size– How many rolls do you typically make? You may need to consider size as an important buying factor.

Shape– While we prefer small round or square pans so you can properly squeeze it into one tight pan, there are larger options such as cookie sheets.

Temperature Limit– Some pans have limits on the max temperature they can withstand in the oven. Most of the time, this is a non-issue as manufacturers make these pans specifically for going into the oven. However, if you know you’re going to be using higher temperatures, this is something you’ll want to pay attention to.

Natural vs non-stick– A lot of bake goods stick to pans pretty well. You’ll have to make the determination whether you want to go with a non-stick pan or a natural pan. With the natural pan you’ll have to use some oil or cooking spray. Non-stick coated pans may limit some things as well. Non-stick coatings typically lower the max temperature a pan can handle; they’re also not dishwasher friendly.

Final Thoughts

Everybody enjoys eating cinnamon rolls. Hopefully we’ve provided you with the best equipment to get the job done. From our round pan options to some larger square pans, there should be something in this list for everybody. If you have a favorite styled pan for cinnamon rolls, let us know in the comments below. Our personal favorite are the smaller round cake pans.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Comment: